New Construction Or Resale Homes - Pros & Cons Of New / Resale Homes

Many of us dream of building their own home according to their preferences – a place where they will feel like themselves, relaxed and sheltered from the outside world.

It’s no wonder that some are ready for the endeavour of having a new home built for them, but we often forget the chance of simply buying a pre-owned home and focus on decorating it the way we want. So, if you are offered a choice, what should you do? Let’s consider the benefits and shortages of each – new construction or resale homes.

1. The cost

In essence, a new home will be far more expensive than a pre-owned home. Today’s market offers slow home turnover results, lowering the prices of older homes to a great extent. On the other hand, building a new home these days is almost 50% more expensive than it used to be, while there are numerous beautiful old homes waiting to be lived in.

The truth is, when it comes to building a new home, it will always be a seller’s market from the moment you start to do business with a builder, while it’s really a buyer’s market when it comes to older homes.

New construction or resale homes?
New construction or resale homes?

The option closest to having a new home is managing to buy a new home that’s already being built, waiting for its first owners.

(Bo’s note: This factor really depends on your local market and the price range you’re looking to buy.)

2. The environmental impact

The fact is that a lot of new material needs to be used when building a new house. And let’s just add the CO2 output and the inevitable urban sprawl to it. Of course, there’s an option to build a LEED-certified home or a tiny, compact home out of reclaimed materials, making the environmental impact almost non-existent.

On the other hand, buying an old house and retro-fit it with energy saving material leaves an even smaller carbon footprint.

3. The quality

Sometimes, newer means better and sometimes it doesn’t. Newer homes have the advantage of zero years behind them, while the old ones spent maybe decades under various weather conditions, becoming ramshackle in the process.

Looking from a different point of view, it’s a fact that today’s homes are nowhere near the old ones when it comes to quality of the material. The result you get is that the internal walls are thicker and more solid, meaning the rooms will be better soundproofed and the walls will endure strong knocks.

New Construction or resale homes? Speak to your REALTOR before deciding
New Construction or resale homes? Speak to your REALTOR before deciding

The secret is in the importance of craftsmanship and pride that contributed to building strong, durable houses in the past. Local builders could be found on every step and they put a lot of hard and quality work into the building process, while today’s building industry gives priority to speed and low-cost material. It’s not about getting the job right anymore; it’s about getting it done quickly.

(Bo’s note: “Many new home builders install electric furnaces instead of natural gas ones.  These electric models DO carry certain advantages, however most of those benefits are in the builders favour, NOT the home owner.  Check out the pros and cons of electric furnaces in this article.)

4. The hard and long-lasting work

A new dream house comes with a price – be ready for weeks of micromanagement, unforeseeable problems, difficult decision-making and frustration almost every single day. This won’t be too much of an issue if you are a patient person and you have a lot of time to invest in your new home. However, if time and stress-free life are your priorities, it’s so much easier to just pick an older home and spend the time that you saved on adjusting it to your needs.

For example, everyone needs quality air conditioning. With an old home, you can also save time by hiring an aircon service to do this very quickly, as there’s no middleman between you and the manufacturer. But when you’re building from scratch, you have to make sure that your contractors take air conditioning into account, so that you won’t be in trouble the moment you need to move in, and realize that air conditioning would take even more work.

New Construction or resale home?
New Construction or resale home? Talk to your real estate agent about the advantages of each

(Bo’s note: One of the challenges in Winnipeg’s real estate market is that most builders do not have a huge selection of homes, already built and ready to buy.  Most are built on special order for buyers.  The problem: buyers can’t see what they’re getting, except in mock ups, brochures and samples.  On the other hand, when looking at a re-sale home, you can see what you’re getting – it’s already fully finished)

5. Home warranties

The good thing about having a new home is that the warranties begin from the closing date of the home, meaning that all appliances have at least 1-year guarantee, while appliance manufacturers offer even extended warranties. Still, it can also be done in a pre-owned home, as the seller and the buyer can negotiate an extended warranty on most home appliances. Even though there’s always the “What if” question when it comes to pre-owned homes, let’s just remind ourselves of the fact that warranties in new homes don’t usually cover tear and improper use, which, let’s be honest, happens very often.

6. Hidden Extras

There are a lot of things we have come to take for granted, which are NOT included in most new construction homes.  Items such as Central Air, garage door openers, lawn, fences, window coverings, decks and many more. Make sure you understand WHAT is included, and what is not.

New Construction or Resale: Summary

Deciding whether to buy a new construction or resale home is not an easy choice. It’s important to be aware of all the pros and cons of each of these two options.

The most important thing here is to decide first how much money you are willing to spend and how much time and effort you have the luxury to invest in any of these endeavours.  Then, schedule a meeting with a real estate agent to discuss your various options.


Our Latest Web-Stories
Never miss an episode of our real estate podcast. Install our FREE Podcast App available on iOS and Android. For your Apple Devices, click here to install our iOS App. For your Android Devices, click here to install our Android App. Check my videos on Youtube

Check out our Podcast


Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
David Mureithi
Rate this post :

It comes with what you desire. If you basically prefer new, or old, you will go for it. However, price is another factor that plays a lot in your choice.


It’s really hard to decide whether to buy an old house or build a new one. It is more expensive to build a new one. Thanks for giving us the pros and cons when it comes to buying or building a house. This will definitely help me in the future.

Maury Cheskes

It seems buying a used home is the better option. The fact that older homes were built with sturdier walls and are way cheaper are huge selling points. It obviously depends if you’re a huge home connoisseur or looking for something practical.


Never knew about these types of information when it comes to new construction or reselling houses. I should also take note about this information. Thank you for the lovely and informative article as usual.

Macky Antonio

I’m on the side of resale homes here. While it would be dreamy to have your home built from scratch, I don’t think that the most practical thing to do nowadays. You’re right, there are lot of beautiful “old” homes that are already built and waiting to be occupied. If there are some aspects of the built house that does not suit your taste, then have that part renovated.

David Tjoe
Rate this post :

Yes, especially nowadays it’s not easy to find the desired strategic location. Then after that, you will be faced with another difficult choice – by choosing between a new construction or a re-sale home. You must have the budget planning needed so that you don’t make wrong and regretful decisions afterwards. Home, sweet Home!

Tom Esthber

My family has been renting different homes for so long, and from my experience, the homes always start to break down after a couple of months. I would prefer constructing a new home for them to be honest.

Scott Summerrs
Rate this post :

I will go for buying a house most of the time, In particular if the factors line up. By that I mean budget, location and clean paperwork. Construction is not bad by all means but to me it seems to be more of a hassle.

Sindey Moreno
Rate this post :

I guess it depends on the market, many people would prefer to buy a new house but sometimes is more convenient to buy a used house.

Aissa Jo Quizon

It’s nice that there are a lot of things outlined in this article which would help people in choosing whether they’d like to get a newly constructed house or move into a house previously owned by other people.

Of course, I would choose quality, and if given that I have the necessary budget for building a new house I’ll go for it. I’m not exactly comfortable buying pre-owned homes. More often than not, they cost more than the average newly built one because of having to probably renovate.

Share via
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x